Increasing transparency in aid delivery

Posted on:13-05-13

Mehjabeen Jagmag, Accountability Initiative

As part of the PAISA project that tracks expenditure in elementary education in India, we collect information from state and district offices, over and above our school-level surveys. While we do face roadblocks when collecting this information, headmasters, as well as block and district and state-level officials, are usually forthcoming with their opinions and open about sharing their documents with us. I would attribute this to the assumption one makes, that if the government is spending public money to provide a public good, one can ask questions about how and when this money was spent and what the outcome was. Read more »

DLHS 4 won’t include 9 low performing States

Posted on:08-05-13

Ambrish Dongre, Accountability Initiative

There has always been a criticism that government schemes and programmes are not evaluated rigorously. The idea of having an Independent Evaluation Office to provide “impartial and objective assessment of various public programmes and improve the effectiveness of public interventions” has not moved beyond interviewing a few well-known researchers. And then there were reports that the National Family Health Survey (NFHS) would be discontinued. Though that did not happen, it seems that the fourth and ongoing round of District Level Health Survey (DLHS), DLHS 4, has paid the price for keeping the NFHS. Read more »

Navigating the Subsidised Grain Delivery Labyrinth

Posted on:02-05-13

Shailey Tucker and Vibhu Tewary, Accountability Initiative

The Mid-Day Meal (MDM) Scheme, the world’s largest school-feeding programme,[1] guarantees a hot, cooked meal to each school-going child between the ages of 6 and 14 years in government elementary schools. Its main objectives are to increase enrolment, attendance and retention, while also improving the nutritional status of students. The scheme is beset with several problems in its implementation.[2]One of the most critical issues being that of delivery of quality grains to schools.We had recentlycarried out a qualitative study on the functioning of the MDMS scheme in a few districts. This blog highlights a number of issues we discovered which essentially stall the final delivery of grain to schools. Read more »

The Right to (Right) Information

Posted on:22-03-13

Aishwarya Panicker, Accountability Initiative                            

I attended the Fourth National Right to Information (RTI) Convention in Hyderabad, organized by the National Campaign for People’s Right to Information (NCPRI) on the 17th and 18th of February, 2013. In the midst of RTI legends, Nikhil Dey and Aruna Roy, were a large number of supporters that included social scientists, professors, government officials, and community workers. Several other genuinely-interested citizens, most of whom have used the RTI to avail public information, were also present. The Convention, in essence, was an initiative to encourage a conversation on the multiple facets around transparency, as well as help shape the priorities of the NCPRI in terms of what their focus areas for the next two years should be. Read more »

How is Janani Suraksha Yojana performing in backward districts of India? - Part 3

Posted on:05-03-13

So far we have seen that Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY) has been successful in increasing institutional deliveries. The scheme is performing well even in some of the most backward districts in the country. But there is a scope for improvement in its functioning especially with regards to delays in receiving benefits, payment of bribes and other problems in receiving the benefits.

This part of the series discusses the role of the Accredited Social Health Workers (ASHA) and the Auxiliary Nurse Mid-wife (ANM). Read more »

Union Budget Speech 2013-14: Highlights from the Social Sector

Posted on:28-02-13

Uthara Ganesh and Avani Kapur

Highlights for focal ministries:

  1. The Ministry of Rural Development has been allocated a total of Rs 80,194 crore, which is an increase of as much as 46 percent from the revised estimates of 2012-13. Much of this increase can be attributed to the increase in allocations to the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana. The budget estimates for the Ministry of Rural Development for the year 2012-13 stood at Rs 90,435 crores.
  2. The Ministry of Human Resource Development has been allocated with Rs 65,867 crores, an increase of 17 percent over the revised estimates of 2012-13.
  3. The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has received an allocation of Rs 37,330 crores, a meager rise from Rs 34,488 crores allocated in the budgetary estimates of 2012-13.
  4. The Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation has received an allocation of Rs 15,260 crores, an increase from Rs 13000 crores, which was the revised estimated allocation to the ministry in 2012-13.

Highlights from the Economic Survey 2012-13

Posted on:27-02-13

Avani Kapur and Uthara Ganesh

General Trends in Social Sector Allocations:

  • GOI expenditure on social services and rural development combined (Plan and non-Plan) has seen an increase from 14.77 per cent in FY 2007-8 to 17.39 per cent in FY 2012-13 (Budget Estimates [BE]).
  • It is budgeted that 25.1 percent of the total expenditure (GOI and states) will be spent in FY 2012-13. This is an increase from 24.5 percent in FY 2011-12.
  •  The total expenditure (GOI and states combined) on education increased from Rs 291378 crores to Rs 331524 crores. As a percentage of GDP, this amounts to an increase from 3.25 percent to 3.31 percent.
  • The expenditure on health (GOI and states) as a percentage of GDP also increased from 1.29 percent in FY 2011-12 to 1.36 percent in FY 2012-13.

How is Janani Suraksha Yojana performing in backward districts of India? - Part 2

Posted on:19-02-13

Ambrish Dongre and Avani Kapur, Accountability Initiative

As mentioned previously, this blog post discusses the findings from the PAHELI survey with respect to the JSY.

1. Institutional and home deliveries

Out of 3178 deliveries, 48% deliveries took place in government facilities, 9.5% in private facilities, and 42.5% deliveries took place at home (table 1A)[1]. The proportion of deliveries in government facilities is highest in Sundargarh and Rajgarh, followed by Udaipur. Korba, Gumla and Hardoi perform the worst. Read more »

How is Janani Suraksha Yojana performing in backward districts of India? - Part 1

Posted on:14-02-13

Ambrish Dongre and Avani Kapur

The Government of India (GoI) has ambitious plans “to transfer individual benefits from the Government directly into the bank accounts of beneficiaries”[1]. This has given rise to intense debates and discussions on direct cash transfers as a policy tool to administer social-welfare objectives of the government. Unfortunately, there has been a limited discussion of the evidence from cash transfer schemes currently in operation in India. This 4-part blog-post, based on a forthcoming working paper, partially fills this gap by analysing the performance of Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY), a conditional cash transfer scheme aimed at promoting institutional delivery by providing money to women if they deliver in medical facilities. Incentives are also given to the local community health workers, Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs), if they facilitate such deliveries. The data for this exercise comes from PAHELI, a unique attempt to rapidly assess the status of human development, including maternal and child health, in some of the most backward districts in India (click here, here and here to know more about PAHELI)[2]. Read more »

All for One and None for Another? Entitlements, Attendance and Conditional Cash Transfers in Bihar: Part II

Posted on:11-02-13

Shailey Tucker

Since mid-January, Bihar’s public schools have seen great activity as an ambitious campaign to distribute student entitlements was rolled out. These entitlements are given out each year; however, this year there is an added twist in the form of a required attendance rate of 75 per cent between April and September 2012 to be eligible. As mentioned in my last post, the second part of my blog discusses the efficacy with which the distribution campaign has been designed and implemented in Bihar over the past few weeks. It also touches upon the scope for conditional cash transfers in the Indian education context. Read more »